I'm not a doctor and this isn't medical advice - follow your league's rules and your kid's doctor. But I coached youth baseball for six seasons and kept a pitch log for the last three, and the gap between what coaches track and what actually matters is bigger than I expected.
The first season I tracked everything. Pitches per inning, strikes, balls, first-pitch strikes, strikeouts, walks. By midseason the sheet was a mess and I was making decisions from a page full of numbers I never looked at again.
The Numbers That Matter
Four things, and only four.
- Pitches thrown in the game, counted honestly including foul balls and intentional balls.
- High-effort pitches, which I count as anything thrown at max intent - usually the fastballs in a two-strike count.
- Days of rest taken, and whether they were actually rest or "played shortstop instead."
- Throws outside of games, which is the one most coaches never write down.
That last one is where our problem was hiding. A kid throws thirty pitches in a game on Saturday, then takes "rest" by playing three innings at third base and long-tossing for twenty minutes before the game. His arm did not rest. On paper he looked fine.
The Sheet I Keep
One row per pitcher, per day, in a notebook. Nothing else.
Columns
Date, name, game pitches, high-effort pitches, other throws (warm-up, long toss, practice), position played, arm feeling (good, tight, sore), and notes. That's seven columns and it takes about ninety seconds after a game.
What Made It Useful
Writing down the extra throws changed behavior by itself. Once coaches could see a number next to "he also threw twenty-five warm-up tosses," the idea of throwing him again on Tuesday stopped feeling like a judgment call.
What I Stopped Counting
Strikes and balls, for one. I care whether a kid is around the zone, but tracking strike percentage during a game made me coach the count instead of the pitcher. I also stopped counting "bullpen pitches" separately from everything else, because it turned out the mental separation was the problem - a bullpen session is throwing, and the arm doesn't know it's not a game.
The one I'm still unsure about is warm-up throws. Some coaches count every one, some don't count any. I count them as "other throws" without trying to be precise, which seems more honest than pretending they don't exist.
The Bullpen Rule That Saved Us
Our rule was simple: no bullpen session within two days of a game appearance, and no more than one bullpen session between starts. That's it. No drills, no weighted balls, no long toss programs.
For the bullpen itself, we use the $59.97 nine-hole pitching net with the adjustable strike zone, which lets a kid get thirty real reps with a target instead of throwing into open air where every pitch feels fine. The $69.99 premium 7x7ft net with the adjustable batting tee is the one we set up when pitchers and hitters share a session, and the $59.99 7x7ft net with the carry bag goes to away games because the site rarely has anything usable.
The target matters more than people think. Without one, a bullpen session turns into twelve minutes of loose throwing with no intent, which is the worst of both worlds - enough volume to matter, not enough focus to improve anything.
Signs To Shut It Down
I'm not diagnosing anything here, but these were our automatic stops: a kid who shakes his arm between pitches, a kid whose release point suddenly drops, a kid who says "it's tight" instead of "it hurts," and any kid who loses three to four miles per hour without a mechanical reason. The last one is subtle and it shows up before complaints do.
Rest is the intervention I trust most, and it costs nothing.
The Season View
Tournament Weekends
Three games in two days is where logs break down. Our rule: a pitcher who throws in game one doesn't pitch in game three, no exceptions, no matter how good the matchup looks. Coaches hate this rule in the moment. Parents remember it in August.
What The Numbers Looked Like
First season with the log: eleven pitchers, four complaints of arm tightness, one visit to a doctor. Second season with the same rules and better record-keeping on non-game throws: nine pitchers, one complaint, no visits. Same age group, similar talent.
I can't prove causation from two seasons of a youth team. But the log cost me ninety seconds a game, and it changed which decisions felt obvious. That's enough for me.
